Thursday, November 17, 2011
Review: Furthur 11.9.11 Madison Square Garden ~ New York, NY
Words: Carly Shields
Visuals: Dylan Carney via Furthur Facebook
You can always tell when Furthur is in town. We take to the streets of New York City
in droves; we smoke up a storm like there isn’t a citywide ban; we walk around with
our fingers up and ask inquisitive passers by if they have any extras; we walk into
Madison Square Garden 45 minutes after printed show time, and we scream and
shout in that great, echoing entrance hall.
MSG is a wonderful venue for a crowd like the Furthur fans. It’s big enough for all
of us, but they don’t pack out the venue like for Phish, so the walls of people aren’t
too overwhelming. As is so typical of this fan base, maybe a handful of people are in
their actual seats, some by wherever they can put their coat, and the rest dancing in
the isles and darting around the ushers who attempt to keep the railing clear.
I was glad to have been stuck on the will call line for the “Sugar Magnolia” opener
because, in listening to the show, it’s lack of energy would have bothered me and set
a negative tone for the rest of the set. As it was, I darted into the walkway between
the 200 and 300 levels (the best view and sound if you don’t have floor) just in time
for the exciting closing jam and seamless transition to “Scarlet Begonias.” The vocals
were not great for some reason, but they made up for it by letting Sunshine Garcia
(Becker) shine a little herself. “Ramble on Rose” was her moment and the boys
really let those harmonies ring out.
Next on the first set’s hit list was a particularly enticing “Tennessee Jed” with special
guests Larry Campbell and Teresa Williams. These folk-blues stars added a whole
separate level of integrity to the song, with Williams’ vocals making it sound almost
hymnal and Campell’s additional guitar fitting flawlessly with Bobby and John K.
He took up his fiddle as his wife left the stage and created stunning harmonies for a
mellow, but long “Uncle John’s Band.” He kept the sound going through “Eyes of the
World,” adding complicated levels to an already musically rich song. Until this point,
the set had been a wash of singles, albeit great ones, but finally, Furthur pulled
out the first-set-stocks for a beautiful and calming “So Many Roads” sung by our
beloved Jerry impersonator who, if I closed my eyes during this song, would have
transported me back in time. Campbell’s added violin added a depth of emotion that
truly pulled at my heartstrings. The “Box of Rain” that followed was anticlimactic,
unfortunately.
The second set, rather predictably, opened with a party-inducing “Shakedown
Street” that really seemed to rally the crowd, but the jam slowed dramatically to
set up for “The Other One > St. Stephens.” In the pacing of the transition, they lost a
lot of energy, and while the beginning was strong, it lacked support and Phil’s bass
didn’t hit me like it usually does. It got better as the song went on, and “St. Stephens”
was great, retrieving that fullness of sound.
One of my favorite things about a Furthur crowd is the diversity of age, and even
during this fairly low-tempo set, the whole crowd was grooving to each selection,
from senior status men and women to new mommies with their little babies in
headphones to the young teens finally getting their first live Dead experience.
Later in the set, they played a short, but sweet “The Wheel,” maintaining the
slowness, with some fist pumping-bound-to-cover-just-a-little-more-ground-action
sprinkled in. Teresa Williams came back out towards the end of the set for what was
the start of an explosive end, leading off with a cover of Blind Willie Johnson’s “Keep
Your Lamp Trimmed and Burning.” Williams’ passionate vocals combined with
her fiery pink dress, ecstatic stage presence, and the phenomenal reworking of
the song that the band pulled off made for possibly the best cover I’ve heard from
Furthur, including the cleverly planned Beatles selections from 2010. Williams
slipped off stage while the boys slipped easily into a basic, but well-played “Fire on
the Mountain” and, just as was the case with the opener, you could see a “Sunshine
Daydream” closer from a mile away. It was what the show called for, and it made the
crowd go wild. It took on a total party vibe as the band was clearly pleased with the
set and enjoying themselves.
Both Campbell and Williams returned for the “Attics of My Life” encore, which
brought some people to tears, and made others yearn for more Furthur. It wasn’t
the best closing selection for MSG, or for that show or that crowd, but I have no
complaints about the way it sounded. Like “So Many Roads” had a couple hours
previously, this song was a lovely way to wind down and take a second to appreciate
the mastery of these musicians. Some people say that when another band can
play your music better than you, maybe it’s time to stop but as much as I’ve been
disappointed by Furthur before, this show blew me away and made me hope those
boys play ‘til they die (which, as we knew we would be told, hasn’t happened yet
thanks to organ donors). -Carly ShieldsDisclaimer: The views expressed by our contributors, whether in posts, comments, or tweets do not necessarily represent the views of the Oh Kee Pah Blog, it's board members, stock-holders, or employees.
Labels:
2011,
2011 November Furthur,
Carly Shields,
Furthur,
Setlist,
Show Reviews
|
0
comments
Setlist & Other Stuff: Furthur 11.16.11 Schottenstein Center ~ Columbus, OH
![]() |
| photo via @furthurband |
Set One: Deal, Beat It On Down The Line > Easy Wind, Black Throated Wind > Ramble On Rose, High Time, Cumberland Blues, The Mighty Quinn
Set Two: Lost Sailor > Saint of Circumstnace > You Never Give Me Your Money > He's Gone > Scarlet Begonias > Fire on the Mountain, Eyes of the World, Black Peter, The Wheel, Casey Jones
Encore: Touch of Grey
Audio:
Gnomes and Hobbits
Media:
Columbus Dispatch: GD tunes finally flow
Photos:
Furthur Facebook
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Most Active Posts
-
Photo by Dave Vann Set One: Buried Alive, Lonesome Cowboy Bill^, Ha Ha Ha, Sample In A Jar, The Divided Sky, Wolfman's Brother -&...
-
photo via GlowStickWars Edited by: Marco Esquandolas Total time: Frankenstein > Ghost Jam -> Spooky >...
-
Can't believe the first tour of Phish 2.0 kicked off 8 years ago today...Happy Valentines Day! Set 1: My Sweet One, Cover of th...
-
Set One: We're Going to War > Partyin' Peeps, All In Time > #5, Roulette, Women Wine and Song > All In Time Set Two: Miss...
-
official show poster by nate duval Acoustic Set: Theme From The Bottom, Cavern, NICU, Bug, My Friend My Friend, Horse > Silent in th...
-
photo courtesy of Justin Wendt [Hartford '09] Set One: Fee > Rift, Wolfman's Brother, Summer of '89^, Foam, Possom > The ...
-
Set One: Get in the Van > All in Time > Roulette, Anchor Drops, Plunger > Blue Echo > Plunger, Example 1, The Floor Set Tw...
The Archive
- ▼ 2011 (701)
- ► 2010 (1372)
Links
- CashOrTrade.org
- Coventry Music Blog
- Dog Gone Blog
- Food Art
- Glow Stick Wars
- Hidden Track
- John Varvatos Clothing Design
- Live Music Blog
- Mr. Miner's Phish Thoughts
- Online Phish Tour
- PhanArt
- Phish.net
- Phish.net Show Review Archive
- Phish.net Tease Chart
- PhishTwibe
- Pretentious Framing
- The Deadblog
- The Mockingbird Foundation
- The Philzone
- The Phish Archive
- This Week on Lot
- Type II cast
- umphreaks.net
- Walfredo.com
- YEMblog
- ZZYZX'S Phish Stats
Other Stuff
2010
Setlist
2011
2010 Summer Tour
Trey Anastasio
Mike Gordon
Audio
2009
2010 Fall Tour
Fall 09
Blog
Grateful Dead
Show Reviews
Fishman
Page McConnell
Recommended Downloads
Bob Weir
1999
2011 Furthur Spring Tour
2011 Winter Cactus
Daily Audio
Pah's Picks
1998
Podcast
tour dates
Phil Lesh
1997
NYE Miami 2009
Phish3D
TAB
2010 New Year's Run
2011 Winter TAB
Rumors
2000
type II cast
Alpine Valley
Phish3D Reviews
1994
Brendan Bayliss
1996
2003
Watkins Glen
2009 Summer Tour
Album Release
Jake Cinniger
1993
jerry garcia
1989
Album Reviews
Andy Farag
Joel Cummins
Ryan Stasik
1995
Festival 8
Kris Myers
1991
1992
Photo Gallery
Telluride
Webcast
Contests
DVD Release
Bill Kreutzmann
Press Release
Red Rocks
2002
Austin City Limits
Furthur Festival
Mayan Holidaze
ThisWeekOnLot
Coral Sky DVD
Mickey Hart
Summercamp
Tour Review
2006
2011 Summer Tour
30db
Alpine Valley DVD
Deer Creek
Fred Kevorkian
Kevin Shapiro
New Year's Eve 2010
Phil Lesh and Friends
Sunday Morning Dead
The Scorchio Quintet
2005
A/V
Deadheads
Photo
Ratdog
Rothbury
Show Notes
UMbowl
1973
1990
2001
2007
Ali Baba's Tahini
Amanda Green
Brent Mydland
Fourmile Canyon Revival
Limestone
Tickets
Tour Preview
UMBowl II
1972
1978
1980
1986
1987
2003 Winter Tour
Jerry Garcia Band
Oysterhead
Phil and Phriends
Poster
Record Store Day
The Island Tour
1971
1981
1983
1984
1985
1998 Europe Tour
2004
2008
Hands on a Hardbody
Phil Lesh and Phriends


